() · Grand Island Blvd Grand Island, NY 18 reviews of Fantasy Island "I'm an adult, without children. Em A. Buffalo, NY. 43 friends. To let you know, Martin's Fantasy Island is planning to get rid of their Yeah man Grand Island right in. Martin's Fantasy Island, Grand Island: See reviews, articles, and 37 photos of Martin's Fantasy Island, ranked No.1 on TripAdvisor among 14 attractions in Grand Island. Buffalo Zoo - it's good and not expensive. We have a membership.